I gotta agree with Rpg....these axles like any other can be broken, but it usually takes a lot. I've seen 5 ton Rockwells broken. It depends a lot on the driver rather than the equipment.
I regularly wheeled a Ford Bronco II with a Ford 7.5 rear with a locker, c-clip axles,a stock axle shafts and a stock, reverse rotation, twin I beam, Dana 28 up front. Everyone gave me such a hard time about that truck, but I wheeled sensibly and without too much skinny pedal, and with a stock 2.9. I broke a few front axle shafts, but that was usually spinning then catching traction with a bit too much application of throttle. Other than that, I never had much trouble, and went everywhere all my wheeling pals did. Sometimes with the short wheelbase places that others couldn't.
As I see it, use what you want and enjoy it. I have and its always worked out OK for me. So far my 40 year old 715 axles haven't failed me yet.....
"Free advice is worth what you pay for it."™